Skip to main content

Does a film having a similar setting to another necessarily make it a rip off?

Hey guys, it's John, and I'm finally here with my first blog post. Now for my first post I decided to focus on something film related, since I am a big movie guy. And to get this topic rolling, let's start with something that I have loved ever since I was a small child: Disney.


Ah yes, this is a company that have played a huge role in damn near everybody's lives. Everybody has seen at least one Disney film in their lives and everybody knows at least one Disney song word for word by heart. So what's gotten me to focus on Disney today you ask? Well it has something to do with the motherland: Africa.



Now granted Disney has already done a movie set in Africa, and it's called The Lion King. But here's the thing, as much as I love The Lion King, it was just about a bunch of talking animals and I've always wanted a Disney film that focuses on the actual people of Africa and the various rich cultures and folklore that they have to offer. And when I talk about this to some people, they usually agree with me. But of course, there's always that one little prick that says something along the lines of "ugh, why would they need to do another movie set in Africa? It would just be a rip off of The Lion King!". See folks, this right here is what really pisses me off.

And it's not just me, a lot of people get this insanely stupid response whenever they say how cool it would be to have another Disney movie set in Africa. Why is it that people like these think that just because a movie has a similar setting to another makes it a rip off? For one thing, Africa isn't just one big giant Savannah with animals and Bushmen running around. Trust me I've been there before, and there are plenty of cities, towns, mountains, deserts, and beaches around the continent. So if you honestly believe all the images of this continent that the media constantly feeds you, you've got another thing coming. Further more, a film having a similar location to another is not a bad thing in the slightest as long as the film makers give the film it's own unique identity.

For example let's take a look at these two films made by Disney and Dreamworks respectively:
Alright folks, now right off the bat, tell me what these two movies share in common. What's that?They're both set in China and they both feature characters doing martial arts? Correct! Now does this mean that Kung Fu Panda is a rip off of Mulan? Absolutely not! 

Why? Because Mulan is about a girl who runs away from home to take the place of her elderly father in a war against the huns. Now here is where the thing about identity comes in. The things that make Mulan completely unique from Panda is that for one thing, it's based on an ancient Chinese poem titled The Ballad of Hua Mulan. Another thing is that it features, you know, human beings and like all Disney films from the 90's, it's a musical. That and aside from a dragon voiced Eddie Murphy and grumpy ancestral spirits, the film is rather grounded and realistic (well as realistic as a Disney film could get). Now let's take a look at Kung Fu Panda.

What are some things that make Dreamworks' Chinese centric film different from Disney's effort? Well unlike Mulan, Kung Fu Panda is a completely original idea. Also, this movie has anthropomorphic animals doing martial arts, and on top of that, it's certainly a lot more fantastical than Mulan (Seriously, the villain of the third film has been confirmed to have legit superpowers this time around). And lastly, this movie is not a musical. 

See? Even though the location of both films are similar, both Disney and Dreamworks made sure that their respective films had things that made them stand out from the crowd. But let's take a look at some other films that Disney and Pixar have done. The Hunchback of Notredame is about a deformed man under the watch of a cruel judge who wants to be accepted by society, Beauty and the Beast is about a young woman falling in love with a cursed prince, and Ratatouille is about a rat who wants to become a chef. Now what's the one thing that all these movies share in common? They're all set in France. That's it.  Even though all of these movies are set in the same country all three of them have their own unique identity. And it doesn’t stop there, turns out Disney DID have another movie set in Africa. And you know what that movie is called? 
And is Tarzan a rip off of The Lion King in any shape or form? NO! 

 In conclusion, if Disney can give all of the films I mentioned their own identity, then they can do the same for another movie set in the dark continent. Plain and simple. And that folks completes what I have to say on this topic. Until then, I'll see you guys later.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Taiora vs Sorato: Why are we still fighting about this?

So as many of you guys may already know, the long awaited continuation of the Digimon Adventure series titled "Digimon Adventure Tri" is coming later this year. And of course the fans couldn't be more excited, I mean finally after more than a decade, we're finally going to get to see the OG digidestined go on another adventure. And of course there have been tons of speculation going on, such as what the villain is gonna be like, if the 02 characters will make an appearance, whether the other Digimon aside from Agumon or Gabumon will go mega, it's all just so exciting. But of course there's one bit of speculation that has been going around as well, one that is not so positive. I'm of course talking about the shipping. Now for those of you who aren't familiar with the terminology of the Internet, shipping is a term used to describe taking two fictional characters from a series and putting them in a romantic relationship. And if there's anyt...
5 comments
Read more

Could An Alternate Earth Be The Key To #RecastTChalla ?

 Well folks I finally saw “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness” and I loved it! With both this and “Spider-Man No Way Home”, Marvel is going all in on the multiverse saga. But since this is yet another discussion about variants in the MCU, let’s discuss how this all can affect a character we’ve discussed here twice before: King T’Challa a.k.a. The Black Panther.  Now before I go on let me make a disclaimer: This blog post will contain heavy spoilers for Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. So if you have not seen the film, turn away now. You have been warned. With that out of the way let’s begin. Earth 838 In MOM, Doctor Strange and America Chavez are on the run from the Scarlet Witch (aka Wanda Maximoff), and end up in an alternate earth where’s Stephens variant died in the line of duty. We later find out from a variant of Christine that they are in earth 838, while Stephen is from earth 616. Not only that but we also see the Illuminati, consisting of variants...
1 comment
Read more

Fanmade Pokemon Types: Can they work?

Hello ladies and gentlemen. It's been a minute but now I am finally back to blogging. Today, we are going to talk about a video game franchise. One that I have been a loyal fan of for many years. I am talking of course about the Pokemon franchise. Gotta catch em all! Now why am I talking about Pokemon today you may ask? Well it's all about the potential of new types. Now for those of you who don't know, types are properties for Pokemon and their moves. They work in a rock paper scissors style format so that there can be advantages and disadvantages during battles (ex: Water beats fire, Grass beats water, etc.). So far there are 18 elemental types but that hasn't stopped fans from making types of their own over the years and today I'm going to take a look at the 4 most common fan made typings, what I think their strengths and weaknesses should be and if they can make sense enough to work in the actual games. And if you don't see your favorite fan made type...
1 comment
Read more